Regular NSAID Use May Lower Risk for Parkinson's Disease
Adults who regularly take aspirin NSAIDs have a decreased risk of
Parkinson’s disease compared with controls, researchers reported in the
November 6 Neurology. An even stronger effect was observed among
regular nonaspirin NSAID users, according to lead investigator Beate
Ritz, MD, PhD, and colleagues.
The investigators found that risk of Parkinson’s disease among
regular nonaspirin NSAID users was 48% lower than in controls and 56%
lower for those who reported two or more years of use. Regular use of
aspirin was protective only for women, especially among long-term
regular users. However, Dr. Ritz told Neurology Reviews that
she suspects this is because the researchers asked about numbers of
tablets taken per week, and men may be more likely to take the low-dose
aspirin tablets commonly recommended for cardiovascular protection.
These would not provide the anti-inflammatory effect thought to be the
reason for the neuroprotection in women, who were 49% less likely to
develop Parkinson’s disease if they reported more than two years of
regular aspirin use. “Overall, we found that nonaspirin NSAIDs and
aspirin were associated with up to a 40% to 50% decrease in the risk of
Parkinson’s disease in regular users,” said Dr. Ritz, who is a
Professor of Epidemiology at the University of California, Los Angeles.
A PROTECTIVE ROLE FOR NSAIDS
The study included 293 patients with Parkinson’s disease and 286
age-, race-, and gender-matched controls. Participants were asked if
they had taken, at any point in their lifetime, a number of different
types of aspirin or nonaspirin NSAIDs once a week or more for at least
one month. They were also asked about the number of pills taken per day
or week, the length of treatment by month or year, and the age at first
and last use of each drug.
The odds ratios for developing Parkinson’s disease were 0.80 for
regular (at least two pills per week for at least one month) aspirin
users, 0.52 for regular nonaspirin NSAID users, 0.44 for nonaspirin
NSAID users of at least two years, and 0.51 for women with long-term
aspirin use.
Dr. Ritz related that the connection to apparent protection against
Parkinson’s disease was a serendipitous finding in a study designed to
simply document lifetime use of analgesics. “We were just asking about
painkiller use,” she said. She theorized that the link to Parkinson’s
disease became apparent, because, unlike prior case-control studies,
this study included lifetime use (compared with only five to seven
years before disease onset) and did not rely on prescription data.
“Most of this use is not for prescription drugs,” she pointed out.
The duration of use required to produce the apparent protective effect
is unknown, but Dr. Ritz predicted that “regular use of these
medications at age 30 to 50, long before the diagnosis of Parkinson’s
disease,” may be important.
“A protective role for NSAIDs is biologically plausible, although an
understanding of the exact mechanism of NSAIDs’ potential protective
effect remains elusive,” the authors wrote. “NSAIDs may exert their
anti-inflammatory effect by inhibiting proinflammatory cyclooxygenase
(COX) enzymes, which have been implicated in the pathogenesis of
Parkinson’s disease. COX-2 is upregulated in the dopaminergic neurons
of both patients with Parkinson’s disease and mouse models of
Parkinson’s disease.... NSAIDs may also protect against reactive
oxidative species or protect neurons from glutamate-induced toxicity by
inhibiting the activation of nuclear factor-kB.”
In addition, said Dr. Ritz, “Other studies have shown that
inflammatory markers are associated with increased rates of Parkinson’s
disease. Inflammation contributes to brain death in the regions
affected in Parkinson’s disease. The process may be that cells die,
which induces microglia, which leads to a chronic inflammatory process
and more nerve cell death. There is probably a subgroup of people who
are inherently more vulnerable, in whom inflammation triggers
development or progression of Parkinson’s disease. If we could find
ways to identify people at risk, using biomarkers, family history, or
other factors, it might be possible to develop a protective strategy
based on anti-inflammatory drugs.” Dr. Ritz noted that validating such
an approach would be difficult. “It will require identifying currently
healthy people who are at increased risk for Parkinson’s disease,
randomizing them to NSAIDs or aspirin at certain doses versus placebo,
and treating them in their 40s for a disease they would not be
diagnosed with typically until in their 60s,” she said.
OPTIMIZING TREATMENT IN PATIENTS
However, there is little downside risk to routine use of a few
tablets of NSAIDs or aspirin per week, Dr. Ritz pointed out. “If you’re
really worried about Parkinson’s disease, maybe this is an
alternative,” she said. “If the patient has a risk profile, such as
family history, and no indications of risk for gastrointestinal
bleeding or other NSAID-related side effects, why not?” Dr. Ritz and
colleagues are conducting a study in Denmark that will include 2,000 to
3,000 patients with Parkinson’s disease and 30,000 matched case-control
subjects, drawing data on lifetime use of analgesics of all types from
the Danish national health system and pharmacy databases. The
researchers expect to report data on Parkinson’s disease rates and
prescription analgesic use early next year and on lifetime use of all
analgesics (which requires in-depth interviews with patients and
controls) in about two years.
Dr. Ritz emphasized the need for clinicians and researchers to pool
more data from studies of Parkinson’s disease. “This is a rare disease,
and we will learn very little if we don’t learn to share our data,” Dr.
Ritz said. “Studies of 100 patients with Parkinson’s disease here and
there with negative findings do not tell me anything.”
NR
—Janis Kelly
Suggested Reading Bornebroek M, de Lau LM, Haag MD, et al. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and the risk of Parkinson disease. Neuroepidemiology. 2007;28(4):193-196.
Wahner AD, Bronstein JM, Bordelon YM, Ritz B. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs may protect against Parkinson disease. Neurology. 2007;69(19):1836-1842.
Return to table of contents
|
|